What Writers Get Wrong and How to Fix It with J. Y. Yang on Writing Excuses
Ever wonder what writers keep getting wrong without realizing it? In this Writing Excuses episode, J. Y. Yang breaks down those common pitfalls and shares practical fixes you can actually use. It's a must-listen for anyone ready to level up their craft.
Key Lessons from J. Y. Yang on the Writing Excuses Podcast
J. Y. Yang’s appearance on Writing Excuses distills craft advice around character interiority, cultural specificity, and the discipline of revision. Yang emphasizes that compelling protagonists are defined by what they want, what they fear, and the small contradictions between the two, so writers should build scenes that pressure those tensions rather than merely advance plot. Yang also stresses writing from lived emotional truth even in speculative settings, using concrete sensory detail to ground readers in unfamiliar worlds. A key takeaway is character-driven worldbuilding: setting emerges through choices and consequences, not exposition dumps. Finally, Yang advocates iterative drafting and honest beta feedback, treating revision as discovery. For search-friendly craft guidance, focus on actionable techniques—stakes, interiority, and specificity—rather than abstractions.
Q: What’s the fastest way to improve a flat protagonist? A: Identify their core want and fear, then rewrite each scene so a choice forces conflict between them—showing character through action, not explanation.
Why This Episode Stands Out Among Craft Discussions
J. Y. Yang's appearance on Writing Excuses delivers sharp, actionable advice for storytellers. She emphasizes that character-driven storytelling beats plot mechanics every time—readers connect with emotional truth, not elaborate outlines. Yang encourages writers to trust their instincts during drafting and resist over-planning, letting characters reveal the story organically. She also stresses the value of vulnerability on the page, arguing that honest, specific details create universal resonance.
Your characters' desires should drive every scene—if you can't articulate what they want right now, the scene isn't ready.
- Draft instinctively before outlining
- Ground scenes in character desire
- Embrace vulnerability for authentic voice
Yang's Perspective as a Debut Novelist Turned Teacher
J. Y. Yang's Writing Excuses episodes deliver sharp, actionable craft advice for storytellers. She champions character-driven plotting, showing how protagonists' choices and flaws should generate conflict rather than convenient coincidence. Yang stresses specificity in worldbuilding—grounding fantastical elements in sensory, lived detail so readers trust the story. She also explores voice as a tool for intimacy, urging writers to let narration reflect a character's worldview, not just report events. Revision, she insists, is where discovery happens: draft boldly, then cut ruthlessly. Perhaps her most resonant lesson is embracing emotional truth over polished perfection—readers connect with vulnerability, not virtuosity. Her insights remind writers that structure and heart aren't rivals but partners.
Common Mistakes Writers Make When Starting a Story
One of the most common mistakes writers make when starting a story is beginning too early, front-loading backstory and exposition before anything actually happens. Readers need a reason to care before they'll invest in context, so opening with action, tension, or a provocative voice beats explaining a character's entire history. Another frequent error is burying the hook—the compelling question or conflict—deep in the first page instead of leading with it. Writers also overuse throat-clearing openings like waking up, weather descriptions, or mirror scenes, and they often confuse confusion with intrigue by withholding too much information. Strong openings orient the reader quickly, establish stakes, and create a promise the rest of the story must keep.
Q: How soon should conflict appear? Ideally on the first page—not necessarily explosions, but a disruption, tension, or unanswered question that signals change is coming.
Q: Is backstory ever acceptable up front? Rarely. Weave it in later, once readers are invested in the present-tense problem.
Opening with Backstory Instead of Momentum
One of the biggest common mistakes writers make when starting a story is dumping a pile of backstory before anything actually happens. Readers don't need the full family tree on page one—they want a reason to care first. Another trap is starting with the character waking up or staring out a window, which feels flat and overdone. Info-dumping, endless world-building, and vague openings that raise no questions also kill momentum fast. Many writers also begin too early, padding the first pages with scenes that should've been cut. Skip the throat-clearing and jump into action, tension, or a moment that makes the reader curious enough to keep going.
Confusing a Cool Concept with a Compelling Plot
Every story begins with a promise, yet many writers stumble at the starting line. The most common story opening mistakes bloom like weeds: endless weather reports, a protagonist waking to an alarm clock, or paragraphs of backstory dumped before anything happens. Readers want motion, not a lecture. Others bury their hook beneath throat-clearing—the character sipping coffee, staring out a window, thinking about yesterday. Some confuse mystery with confusion, tossing in nameless figures and vague pronouns until the reader gives up. A strong opening raises a question the heart must answer, drops us mid-moment, and trusts us to catch up. Begin with trouble, not with tidying.
Failing to Establish Character Stakes Early
Writers often stumble at the starting line by opening with mundane routines, overloading backstory, or drowning readers writingexcuses.com in world-building before any action happens. A common pitfall is starting too early in the timeline, forcing readers through throat-clearing scenes instead of jumping into conflict. Others confuse confusion with intrigue, withholding so much context that readers feel lost rather than curious. Weak opening lines that lack tension or voice also sink otherwise promising drafts. Avoiding these common story opening mistakes means trusting readers, starting close to the inciting incident, and grounding them in character and stakes within the first few sentences. Hook first, explain later.
Pacing Problems That Sink Promising Manuscripts
Pacing problems are among the most common reasons promising manuscripts fail to land agents and publishers. A story that drags in the opening chapters, lingers too long on backstory, or rushes its climax signals to editors that the writer hasn't mastered narrative momentum. Readers abandon books that stall, and agents reject pages that lack urgency—no matter how beautiful the prose.
Great pacing isn't about speed; it's about making every scene earn its place and every page pull the reader forward.
Uneven rhythm, excessive exposition, and scenes that repeat emotional beats without advancing plot all drain tension. Mastering scene-level pacing transforms a promising draft into a compelling, publishable manuscript.
Rushing Through Emotional Beats
Even the most original story can collapse under weak narrative pacing. Manuscripts drown when scenes linger past their purpose, when exposition smothers momentum, and when every chapter ends without a reason to turn the page. Readers forgive imperfect prose far more easily than they forgive boredom. Problems compound when stakes stay static, subplots sprawl without escalation, and transitions drag like dead weight. A brilliant premise means nothing if the reader never feels compelled to reach the next chapter. Fix pacing early by cutting filler scenes, sharpening conflict, and ensuring each beat earns its place. Otherwise, agents and readers abandon the manuscript long before its promise pays off.
Lingering Too Long in Transitional Scenes
Uneven pacing is one of the most common reasons promising manuscripts fail to land agents or readers. A slow opening pacing problem buries the hook under backstory and description, while rushed climaxes rob key scenes of emotional weight. Manuscripts often stall in the middle, where repetitive conflict or filler scenes drain momentum. Readers tolerate a slow start briefly, but sustained drag or jarring acceleration breaks immersion and invites rejection.
Pacing failures rarely stem from weak plots; they come from mismatched scene length, buried tension, and momentum that stalls exactly when stakes should rise.
Balancing Action, Reflection, and Dialogue
Even the most dazzling premise can drown in poor pacing, dragging readers through saggy middles and rushed finales that feel unearned. Manuscript pacing problems often stem from uneven scene rhythm—too much exposition, not enough tension—or a plot that sprints past emotional beats. Readers crave momentum with breathing room; without it, they disengage. Watch for these common culprits:
- Info-dumps that halt forward motion
- Repetitive internal monologue stalling stakes
- Abrupt time jumps that fracture immersion
- Climaxes resolved too quickly or drawn out
Fix these by calibrating scene length and tension to your story's emotional arc—your promising manuscript deserves to breathe, not sprint or stall.
Character Development Pitfalls and Practical Fixes
In the drafting trenches, writers often stumble into the trap of the “flat protagonist” who reacts to events but never transforms, or the “inconsistent arc” where a character’s growth feels unearned and sudden. These character development pitfalls drain emotional resonance from even the most inventive plots. The practical fix is simple but demanding: map a “before and after” snapshot of your character’s beliefs, then build causal bridges between each shift. Audiences forgive flawed heroes far faster than they forgive a hero who never learns. Give your characters small, repeated choices that reveal incremental change, and let relationships pressure-test their growth. Mastering these practical character fixes turns shallow tropes into living, breathing souls who earn every page they occupy.
Giving Protagonists No Room to Change
Weak character arcs often stem from passive protagonists who react to plot rather than drive it, or from motivations that remain vague and unearned. Avoid flanderization—reducing characters to single traits—by grounding every decision in established wants and fears. Practical fixes include writing a one-line arc summary (“from X to Y”), testing each scene against that arc, and using a character development framework that maps flaw, want, need, and change across the narrative.
- Give characters active goals that force choices
- Show change through behavior, not exposition
- Audit scenes for agency and consequence
Writing Side Characters Who Only Serve the Plot
Weak character arcs often stem from inconsistency, passive protagonists, or sudden personality shifts that break reader trust. To master character development pitfalls and practical fixes, anchor every change in cause and effect: give characters clear wants, flaws, and consequences that force growth. Avoid info-dumping backstory—reveal traits through choices under pressure. Replace coincidence with agency, and test each transformation against established motivation. Use beta readers to flag abrupt shifts, and keep a character bible to track continuity. When revision feels stuck, ask: what does this scene cost the character, and what do they learn?
Using Internal Monologue as a Crutch
Weak character arcs often stem from passive protagonists who react to events rather than drive them, or from motivations left vague until the final act. These character development pitfalls and practical fixes are solvable with deliberate craft. Give every major character a concrete want and a deeper need that conflict, then force choices that cost them something real. Replace backstory dumps with decisive actions under pressure. Track each arc scene by scene to confirm change is earned, not announced. Cut traits that never influence plot, and test every motivation with a simple question: would this character act differently without it? If not, revise until the answer is yes.
Worldbuilding Errors That Distract Readers
Worldbuilding errors distract readers when internal logic breaks: inconsistent geography, technology that contradicts established limits, or cultures that behave according to plot convenience rather than their own stated values. Readers forgive imaginative gaps but not contradictions, because contradictions pull them out of immersion and force them to doubt the story's authority. Consistency audits across timelines, maps, economies, and social rules catch most problems before drafting.
If a rule exists, it must cost something every time it is used, or readers will stop believing the world has stakes.
Watch for info-dump worldbuilding that stalls narrative momentum, and avoid retconning established facts to solve later plot problems—it signals carelessness and erodes trust in the storyteller's control.
Info-Dumping Instead of Implying
She had spent months crafting her fictional kingdom, yet her beta readers kept stumbling over the same jarring details. A desert city with no water source, a medieval army wielding steel swords before steel was invented, a language that changed grammar rules every chapter—these worldbuilding errors that distract readers pulled them out of the story faster than any plot hole. Consistency is the invisible thread that holds a fantasy world together; snap it, and immersion collapses. Even small slips, like inconsistent travel times or cultures that feel copied rather than lived-in, whisper to readers that the world is a stage set, not a reality. The fix? Build rules, then obey them—always.
Overbuilding Details That Never Matter to the Story
Nothing yanks readers out of a story faster than a world that contradicts itself. If your magic system has hard limits in chapter one and suddenly has none in chapter ten, or your medieval village somehow has printed flyers and universal literacy, people notice—and they stop trusting you. These worldbuilding consistency mistakes pile up fast: seasons that don't match the geography, economies that make no sense, or technology that appears only when the plot needs it. Readers will forgive a lot, but not a world that feels improvised. Build your rules early, write them down, and stick to them.
Letting Setting Conflict with Character Logic
Worldbuilding errors that distract readers usually come from inconsistency, not lack of imagination. If your medieval village suddenly has plumbing or your magic system changes rules whenever the plot needs it, readers notice—and they stop trusting the story. Overloading the first chapter with lore dumps, naming things impossibly, or ignoring basic economics (who farms the food?) pulls people out of the moment. The fix is simple: keep internal logic tight, reveal details gradually, and treat your world like a real place with consequences. Build the immersive fictional world first, then let the plot live inside it.
Dialogue Mistakes That Weaken Tension
Dialogue that meanders, over-explains, or answers every question directly drains the life out of a scene. When characters say exactly what they mean and resolve misunderstandings too quickly, narrative tension evaporates. Weak dialogue often suffers from “As you know, Bob” exposition, where characters recite facts purely for the reader's benefit, or from filler exchanges that lack subtext. Great dialogue thrives on what is left unsaid, not on what is spelled out. Avoid having characters constantly agree or apologize, as this softens conflict. Instead, let characters dodge questions, talk past each other, or withhold information. Preserving conversational friction keeps readers leaning in, whereas overly tidy, cooperative dialogue signals that nothing truly at stake is happening.
Characters Who Say Exactly What They Mean
The interrogation scene had everything—a ticking clock, a guilty suspect, a detective out for blood—until the suspect explained his entire alibi in one tidy, uninterrupted speech. Tension bled out of the room like air from a punctured tire. On-the-nose dialogue kills suspense the moment characters say exactly what they feel instead of circling, deflecting, or lying. When everyone answers directly and agrees politely, conflict evaporates. Watch for these tension-killers:
- Characters who over-explain their motives
- Questions answered immediately, with no resistance
- Politeness replacing friction
- Speeches where a sharp exchange belongs
Strong scenes thrive on dialogue that hides as much as it reveals—let your characters dodge, snap, and stall, and the reader will lean in.
Conversations That Recite Information for the Reader
Dialogue that defuses tension often suffers from on-the-nose exposition, where characters explain feelings and backstory instead of revealing them through subtext and conflict. Weak tension also creeps in when every line is agreeable, over-explained, or padded with filler that stalls momentum. Interruptions, evasions, and unspoken agendas keep scenes electric; polite, tidy exchanges drain them. Watch for these common culprits:
- Characters stating exactly what they mean
- Repeated information the reader already knows
- Evenly balanced turn-taking with no power struggle
- Reactions that arrive too late or too calmly
Every line of dialogue should cost someone something. Cut the comfort and let friction do the work.
Missing Subtext in Confrontational Scenes
She had him cornered, the confession seconds from spilling—then she asked how his day was. Tension deflated like a punctured tire. Dialogue mistakes that weaken tension often hide in plain courtesy: characters over-explain motives, answerquestions too directly, or trade pleasantries mid-standoff. Every line should push or resist. Watch for these culprits:
- Overly polite exchanges that soften conflict
- On-the-nose explanations instead of evasion
- Evenly matched banter with no stakes
- Premature reveals that release pressure too early
Keep characters dodging, deflecting, and wanting—tension lives in what's withheld, not what's explained.
Revision Strategies Yang Recommends for Fixing Drafts
Yang advocates a systematic, multi-pass approach to revision that separates big-picture concerns from sentence-level polish. She recommends beginning with a reverse outline to test whether each paragraph advances a clear thesis, then restructuring arguments for logical flow before touching grammar or word choice. For sentence-level clarity and concision, Yang advises reading drafts aloud, cutting redundancies, and strengthening verbs. She also encourages writers to solicit targeted reader feedback and to treat revision as recursive rather than linear—returning to earlier passes as new insights emerge. Crucially, she recommends prioritizing global revisions over cosmetic edits, since fixing commas in a paragraph destined for deletion wastes effort. By sequencing revisions from macro to micro, writers can transform rough drafts into coherent, persuasive prose with far greater efficiency.
Reading Aloud to Catch Awkward Prose
Yang recommends a systematic approach to draft revision strategies that begins with global concerns before local ones. She advises writers to first read the entire draft aloud to identify structural weaknesses, then assess whether the thesis and organization serve the argument's purpose. After addressing big-picture issues, writers should tackle paragraph-level coherence, ensuring each section connects logically to the next. Yang emphasizes separating revision from editing so that surface errors don't distract from substantive improvements. Revise in passes—one for structure, one for clarity, one for mechanics—rather than attempting everything at once. She also encourages writers to seek feedback from readers who can spot gaps the author overlooks.
Cutting the First Chapter and Starting Later
Yang’s approach to fixing drafts is all about practical revision strategies for stronger writing. Instead of rewriting everything at once, she suggests tackling big-picture issues first—think argument, structure, and flow—before sweating the small stuff like grammar. She’s a big fan of reading your draft out loud to catch awkward spots, and she recommends stepping away for a bit so you can return with fresh eyes. One trick she swears by is reverse outlining, where you summarize each paragraph to check if your logic actually holds up. She also pushes for targeted feedback from real readers, not just spellcheck.
Using Beta Readers to Spot Blind Spots
When Yang sits down with a messy draft, she doesn't dive straight into line edits—she first steps back to see the whole picture, a habit that reflects her broader revision strategies for fixing drafts. She recommends reading the draft aloud to catch awkward rhythms, then reverse-outlining each paragraph to confirm every claim earns its place. Only after structural repairs does she hunt for repetition, weak verbs, and vague phrasing. Her final pass is a checklist:
- Does the opening promise something the ending delivers?
- Can any sentence be shorter?
- Would a skeptical reader stumble here?
By layering big-picture and sentence-level fixes, Yang turns revision from dread into a detective game.
How Writers Misunderstand Feedback and Criticism
Writers often misunderstand feedback and criticism because they conflate the work with their identity, hearing “this scene drags” as “you are a failure.” This emotional fusion triggers defensiveness, causing them to either dismiss all input or blindly implement every suggestion without filtering it through their own vision. Many also mistake vagueness for uselessness, ignoring that a reader's confusion signals a real gap in clarity rather than a personal attack. The most damaging error is treating constructive criticism as a verdict instead of a diagnostic tool. Writers who learn to separate self-worth from the draft, ask clarifying questions, and test feedback against their story's intent transform criticism into a powerful revision engine rather than a source of paralysis.
Treating Every Critique as a Mandatory Change
Writers often hear feedback as a verdict on their talent rather than a note on the work, which is why constructive criticism for writers can sting even when it's meant to help. Instead of asking what a reader struggled with, many defensively explain the scene or rewrite in secret frustration. The trick is to treat comments as data, not judgment: note patterns, ask clarifying questions, and decide what serves the story. Feedback is a mirror for the draft, not a measure of the person holding the pen.
Defending the Draft Instead of Diagnosing the Problem
Writers often misunderstand feedback because they treat criticism as a judgment of their talent rather than an evaluation of the text. This emotional detachment from feedback leads many authors to either reject useful input defensively or accept every suggestion indiscriminately. Common misunderstandings include confusing personal preference with objective error, interpreting requests for clarification as attacks on their voice, and assuming that praise validates every stylistic choice. Revision requires separating the self from the work, yet writers frequently conflate the two. Learning to ask clarifying questions, weigh feedback against their intended audience, and distinguish between craft-level and taste-level comments helps writers use criticism productively instead of feeling threatened by it.
Separating Personal Taste from Craft Issues
Writers often hear feedback as a verdict on their talent rather than a note on the draft, which is the biggest feedback and criticism misunderstanding in writing workshops. Criticism stings because the work feels personal, so many writers either defend every choice or silently rewrite everything to please one reader. Both reactions skip the useful part: figuring out what the comment actually points to. Vague notes like “I didn't connect” usually signal a craft problem, not a character flaw, and smart writers ask clarifying questions before revising. Treating each critique as data instead of a judgment keeps the ego out of it and turns messy opinions into clear, actionable edits.
Mindset Traps That Hold Writers Back
One of the biggest mindset traps that hold writers back is perfectionism—the endless urge to polish every sentence before moving on. That habit kills momentum and makes finishing anything feel impossible. Another sneaky trap is comparison: scrolling through published work and deciding you're not “real” enough yet. Imposter syndrome creeps in too, whispering that your ideas aren't original or your voice doesn't matter. Then there's fear of judgment, which convinces you to play it safe and write bland, forgettable stuff. Add procrastination disguised as “research” and you've got a recipe for stalled drafts. The fix? Recognize these mindset traps that hold writers back, lower the stakes, and just get words on the Neon Yang page—editing comes later.
Waiting for Inspiration Instead of Building Habits
Even skilled writers fall prey to mindset traps that hold writers back, and recognizing them is the first step to breaking free. Perfectionism convinces you the draft is never ready, so nothing ships. Fear of judgment keeps bold ideas locked in notebooks. Comparison turns your unique voice into a pale imitation of someone else's success. Imposter syndrome whispers that you don't deserve the byline. Fixed-mindset thinking treats every rejection as proof of permanent failure rather than useful data. The cure is simple but uncomfortable: ship imperfect work, separate your identity from the outcome, and treat every draft as an experiment. Name the trap, then deliberately choose the growth-oriented response.
Comparing Early Drafts to Finished Novels
Ever stared at a blank page convinced you're just not “a real writer”? That's one of the biggest mindset traps that hold writers back—and it shows up in sneaky ways. Perfectionism makes you rewrite the same sentence ten times instead of finishing a draft. Fear of judgment keeps your work hidden in a folder nobody sees. Comparison turns every published author into proof you're falling behind. Imposter syndrome whispers that you got lucky and everyone will find out. And waiting for “inspiration” becomes a fancy excuse for procrastination.
The truth is, no one feels ready—they just start anyway.
Spot the trap, name it, and write past it. Your first draft doesn't need to be good; it just needs to exist.
Fear of Writing Badly as a Block to Progress
Every writer knows the sting of the blank page, but the real culprit often lurks deeper: mindset traps that hold writers back. Sarah spent months polishing chapter one, convinced perfection was the only path to publication—meanwhile, her draft gathered dust and her confidence frayed. She isn't alone. Fear of judgment, comparison to published authors, and the illusion that talent should feel effortless quietly sabotage progress. These traps disguise themselves as diligence, turning revision into avoidance and doubt into paralysis. The fix begins with naming them: perfectionism, impostor syndrome, and the myth of the inspired genius. Once Sarah reframed her draft as a stepping stone rather than a masterpiece, words finally flowed. Awareness, not talent, broke the spell.
Actionable Takeaways from the Conversation
Turn the conversation into momentum by assigning one owner and one deadline to every idea captured, so nothing evaporates after the call ends. Prioritize the top three actions that directly impact organic search visibility, then document them in a shared tracker everyone can see. Schedule a quick follow-up within a week to review progress and remove blockers before they snowball. Pair each takeaway with a measurable success metric, whether that's ranking movement, traffic lift, or content shipped, so accountability stays concrete. Finally, bake these habits into your routine and revisit them monthly to refine your SEO strategy based on real results rather than assumptions.
Checklists for Self-Editing After the First Draft
Participants should convert discussion insights into immediate operational changes by assigning clear owners, deadlines, and success metrics to each decision. Key actionable takeaways from the conversation include documenting agreements in a shared repository, scheduling follow-up reviews, and prioritizing the highest-impact items first.
Assigning a single accountable owner to every takeaway dramatically increases the likelihood of follow-through.
Teams should also establish a simple tracking mechanism to monitor progress and flag blockers early. Finally, circulate a concise summary to all stakeholders so expectations stay aligned and momentum is preserved between meetings.
Questions to Ask Before Killing a Scene
Turn discussion into momentum by assigning every insight an owner, a deadline, and a measurable outcome. Capture decisions in a shared action log, convert vague intentions into specific next steps, and review progress at the start of each meeting. Prioritize the two or three highest-impact items rather than spreading effort thin, and flag dependencies early to prevent bottlenecks.
- Assign one owner per action item
- Set a due date and success metric
- Review open items weekly
Embedding these actionable takeaways from the conversation into your workflow ensures accountability and sustained follow-through.
Building a Personal Revision Workflow
When the team finally closed the loop on their discussion, the real work began: turning insight into motion. They committed to assigning clear owners to every open item, setting a short 48-hour deadline for the first follow-up, and documenting decisions in a shared space so nothing slipped through the cracks. The biggest shift came from prioritizing action over analysis, ensuring each meeting produced at least one concrete next step. These actionable takeaways from the conversation transformed talk into traction, giving everyone a simple, repeatable rhythm for accountability and progress.